Why Do We Keep Having the Same Fight? Couples Counselling in Vancouver

این مقاله به زبان فارسی: چرا همیشه همان دعوا را تکرار می‌کنیم؟ زوج‌درمانی در ونکوور

Why Do We Keep Having the Same Fight? Couples Counselling in Vancouver

If you and your partner keep circling back to the same argument — about money, chores, the in-laws, how you spend weekends — you are not failing at communication. You are experiencing what John Gottman calls a perpetual problem; according to the Gottman Institute, 69 percent of relationship conflict is about perpetual problems (Fulwiler, 2012). These disputes do not resolve because they are rooted in fundamental differences in personality, values, or life dreams rather than in a single solvable misunderstanding. The good news: couples who learn to dialogue about perpetual problems rather than “solve” them report higher satisfaction and stay together at significantly higher rates (Gottman & Levenson, 2000). In Vancouver, where the cost of housing, bicultural pressures, and long commutes add fuel to recurring disagreements, understanding why the same fight keeps happening is the first step toward a calmer home.

What exactly is a perpetual problem in a relationship?

Gottman and Levenson’s (2000) research team followed couples over 14 years and found two distinct conflict types. Solvable problems are situational — who picks up the kids on Tuesday, whether the thermostat stays at 20 or 22. They respond to compromise. Perpetual problems are different: they reflect enduring differences between two people — one partner values spontaneity while the other needs predictability; one wants closeness while the other needs personal space. Because neither person is “wrong,” the disagreement never fully closes. Gottman (1999) found that the way couples managed perpetual problems — not whether they resolved them — predicted whether the marriage remained stable over time.

The 69-percent figure does not mean the relationship is broken.

Why does the same argument feel worse every time?

When a perpetual problem goes unaddressed, Gottman’s model predicts it becomes gridlocked: both partners dig in, humour and affection disappear from the conversation, and each mention of the topic triggers physiological flooding — elevated heart rate, shallow breathing, the feeling of being overwhelmed (Gottman & Silver, 2015). Over months or years, gridlock breeds emotional distance. One or both partners start to believe the other simply does not care.

Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy offers a useful lens here. IFS, developed by Richard Schwartz (Schwartz & Sweezy, 2019) and applied to couples work by Herbine-Blank et al. (2016), proposes that each person carries internal “parts” — protectors that guard vulnerable feelings (called exiles). When a perpetual conflict touches an exile — say, a deep fear of being controlled, or an old wound around not being enough — a protector part takes over. One partner’s protector might look like loud criticism; the other’s might look like silent withdrawal. The surface topic is the dishes; the underground battle is protector versus protector, each trying to keep its person safe, and each making the other person’s protector work harder.

That is why it feels like the same fight regardless of the topic. The choreography — pursue, withdraw, escalate, shut down — is driven by parts, not by the dishes.

Wondering whether your pattern can change? You can text or call Samuel directly — no receptionist, no intake forms — at 604-721-0604 or WhatsApp.

How does couples counselling help with perpetual problems?

In session, Samuel draws on both Gottman Method interventions and IFS-informed techniques:

1. Mapping the cycle. The couple identifies the specific trigger → protector → reaction → counter-reaction loop. Seeing the pattern on paper (or on a whiteboard in session) externalises it: the enemy becomes the cycle, not the partner.

2. Gottman’s Dreams-Within-Conflict conversation. Each partner takes a turn as speaker and listener, exploring the life dream, childhood experience, or core value that fuels their position (Gottman & Silver, 2015). The goal is not agreement — it is understanding. Gottman’s research showed that couples who practised this conversation moved perpetual problems from gridlock to dialogue and reported feeling “heard” even when the disagreement remained.

3. IFS unblending. When a protector part has taken over, the person is “blended” — they are the anger or the numbness (Schwartz & Sweezy, 2019). Unblending is the practice of noticing the part (“I can feel my chest tightening — that’s my firefighter part”) and gently separating from it so the person’s core Self — calm, curious, compassionate — can re-enter the conversation. When both partners are in Self, even a perpetual problem becomes a manageable difference.

4. Repair attempts. Gottman’s research identifies the repair attempt — any statement or gesture that de-escalates tension during a fight — as the single strongest predictor of relationship stability (Gottman & Silver, 2015). Couples practise making and receiving repairs (“I’m sorry, that came out harsh — can I try again?”) until the skill becomes automatic.

A free 20-minute intro call lets you describe what is happening and hear how Samuel would approach it — no receptionist, no forms, just a direct conversation. Evenings are available. Book a call or phone 604-721-0604.

Can the same fight actually strengthen a relationship?

Paradoxically, yes. Gottman’s “masters of marriage” — the couples who stayed together and remained satisfied — did not avoid perpetual problems (Gottman & Silver, 2015). They developed what Gottman calls dialogue around them: a way of returning to the topic with gentleness, injecting humour, acknowledging the partner’s perspective, and accepting influence. Gottman and Levenson’s (2000) 14-year longitudinal data showed that these couples’ perpetual problems stayed essentially the same over the study period, yet relationship satisfaction remained high because the affect surrounding the discussion shifted from negative to neutral or even warm.

IFS frames this as both partners learning to lead from Self rather than from protectors (Schwartz & Sweezy, 2019). When the partner who tends to pursue can say, “I notice my anxious part wants to push this — let me slow down,” and the partner who tends to withdraw can say, “I notice my shutdown part is pulling me away — I’m going to stay,” the old choreography breaks. The fight is still “about” the same thing. But the experience of having it is completely different.

What role do cultural and financial pressures play in Vancouver?

Vancouver’s housing costs, multicultural fabric, and geographic distance from extended family create a unique pressure cooker. A bicultural couple — one partner raised in a collectivist family, the other in an individualist one — may discover that what looks like a disagreement about holiday plans is actually a perpetual problem about whose family of origin gets priority.

Samuel works with couples navigating these intersections — including Farsi-speaking Iranian-Canadian couples and families adjusting to life in BC — and brings 25 years of clinical experience across cultures, including early career work in Red Crescent refugee camps and Canadian veterans’ programmes.

Fees may be covered, depending on eligibility, by ICBC, CVAP, FNHA, IFHP, RCMP, VAC, and most other insurers, and direct billing is available — so cost does not need to be the barrier that keeps a perpetual problem grinding on.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal for couples to fight about the same things for years?

Yes. According to the Gottman Institute, 69 percent of relationship conflict is about perpetual problems, which are grounded in fundamental differences in personality or lifestyle needs (Fulwiler, 2012). What matters is how the couple manages them.

What is the difference between a perpetual problem and a solvable problem?

A solvable problem is situational (scheduling, logistics) and responds to compromise. A perpetual problem reflects a fundamental difference between two people — introversion vs. extroversion, different financial philosophies, different needs for closeness — and requires ongoing dialogue rather than a one-time fix (Gottman & Silver, 2015).

What does “gridlock” mean in Gottman’s model?

Gridlock is what happens when a perpetual problem goes unaddressed for too long: both partners entrench, humour and affection leave the conversation, and even mentioning the topic triggers flooding (Gottman & Silver, 2015). Gridlocked couples often feel hopeless, but the Gottman Dreams-Within-Conflict intervention is specifically designed to move them back to dialogue.

How does IFS therapy help with repeating arguments?

Internal Family Systems therapy helps each partner recognise the protective parts — the inner critic, the withdrawer, the fixer — that hijack conversations (Schwartz & Sweezy, 2019). Once a person can notice and “unblend” from a protector part, their core Self re-enters the discussion with curiosity and calm, breaking the old pursue-withdraw cycle.

How many sessions does it usually take to see a change?

The number of sessions needed varies from person to person. Deeper work on the underlying exiles and attachment injuries may continue for several months, but the immediate relief of understanding the pattern often comes quickly.

Can couples counselling help even if only one partner wants to come?

Samuel offers both individual and couples formats.

Do you offer evening appointments?

Yes. Sessions are available evenings, in person at the downtown Vancouver office (1300–1500 West Georgia Street) and by secure video across British Columbia.

Is couples counselling covered by insurance in BC?

Fees may be covered, depending on eligibility, by ICBC, CVAP, FNHA, IFHP, RCMP, VAC, and most extended health plans, and direct billing is available. A Registered Clinical Counsellor (RCC) designation qualifies under most benefit plans.

For more on how couples and family therapy works at this practice, visit the Couples & Family Therapy page.

Book a free 20-minute call

Call or text 604-721-0604, message on WhatsApp at the same number, or book at drsamuel.ca/book-a-call/. Appointments are available 7am–9pm, by appointment only, in person in downtown Vancouver or by secure video anywhere in BC. More detail: Couples and Family Therapy. جلسات به فارسی برگزار می‌شود.

Disclaimer: This article is for general-interest purposes only and does not constitute professional advice, diagnosis, or treatment. Consult a qualified professional for any mental-health decisions. If you are in crisis, call 911 or go to your nearest emergency department.

Written with expert editorial assistance.

References

  • Gottman, J. M. (1999). What predicts change in marital interaction over time? A study of alternative models. Family Process, 38(2), 143–158. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1545-5300.1999.00143.x

  • Gottman, J. M., & Levenson, R. W. (2000). The timing of divorce: Predicting when a couple will divorce over a 14-year period. Journal of Marriage and Family, 62(3), 737–745. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1741-3737.2000.00737.x

  • Gottman, J. M., & Silver, N. (2015). The seven principles for making marriage work (rev. ed.). Harmony Books.

  • Herbine-Blank, T., Kerpelman, D. M., & Sweezy, M. (2015). Intimacy from the Inside Out: Courage and Compassion in Couple Therapy. https://doi.org/10.4324/9781315886145
  • Schwartz, R., & Goldsmith, J. (2019). Internal Family Systems in Family Therapy. Encyclopedia of Couple and Family Therapy, 1575–1580. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-49425-8_199
  • Fulwiler, M. (2012, July 2). Managing conflict: Solvable vs. perpetual problems. The Gottman Institute. https://www.gottman.com/blog/managing-conflict-solvable-vs-perpetual-problems/

Notice: For general interest only; may contain inaccuracies. Not a diagnosis, treatment, prognosis, or professional, clinical, or legal advice. Reading this creates no counsellor-client relationship. By reading this page, you agree to these terms. Full disclaimer. In an emergency, call 911.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This page provides general information only and is not medical, psychological or legal advice.

این صفحه صرفاً اطلاعات عمومی ارائه می‌دهد و توصیه پزشکی، روان‌شناختی یا حقوقی نیست.

Dr SamuelCounselling · Therapy · Neurofeedback Certified Trauma Professional (CTP) — Evergreen CertificationsCertified Youth Mental Health Specialist (CYMHS) — Evergreen CertificationsCertified in Dialectical Behavior Therapy (C-DBT) — Evergreen Certifications
Call Now — FreeDirect line · No formsتماس مستقیم با ساموئل بدون دخالت منشی WhatsApp / Textواتساپ / پیامک Request a Callbackدرخواست تماس کتبی

Suite 1300, 1500 West Georgia Street, Vancouver, BC

6047210604

[email protected]

AFFILIATED WITH
BCACC
RCC
BCACC RCC
CCPA
CCC
CCPA CCC
✚
Red Cross (IFRC)
⛰
Hollyburn Support
☀
Sun Life Lumino
SHIFA
Shifa Therapy
FNHA
FNHA Provider
Scroll to Top