این مقاله به زبان فارسی: شروع تند دعوا: چرا سه دقیقهٔ اول بحث اینقدر مهم است — مشاورهٔ زوج در ونکوور
Short answer: How a disagreement begins appears to shape how it ends. In a six-year study of 124 newlywed couples, Carrère and Gottman (1999) reported that “it was possible to predict marital outcome over a 6-year period using just the first 3 minutes of data for both husbands and wives” (p. 293). The University of Washington (1999), announcing the study, summarised the finding as “the startup of the conflict discussion is key in predicting divorce or marital stability.” Research also suggests that conflict itself is not the problem: Gordon and Chen (2016) found conflict was linked to lower satisfaction only among people who felt their partner did not understand them.
What did the “first three minutes” study actually find?
Carrère and Gottman (1999) coded the conflict discussions of 124 newlywed couples using the Specific Affect Coding System, dividing the data into positive, negative and positive-minus-negative affect for five 3-minute intervals. They reported that “it was possible to predict marital outcome over a 6-year period using just the first 3 minutes of data for both husbands and wives” (Carrère & Gottman, 1999, p. 293). The abstract adds that “for husbands this prediction improved as the groups diverged in the remaining 12 minutes; for wives the prediction remained equally powerful for the remaining 12 minutes as it had been in the first 3 minutes” (Carrère & Gottman, 1999, p. 293).
According to the University of Washington (1999), the researchers videotaped problem discussions of couples who had been married for less than nine months, and concluded that “it is possible to predict which newlywed couples will divorce from the way partners interact in just the first three minutes of a discussion about an area of continuing disagreement.”
Recognise this pattern? Text or WhatsApp a single line to 604-721-0604 and Samuel will call you back.
What is a “harsh startup”?
In the Gottman research tradition, the “startup” is how a person raises a problem at the beginning of a conflict discussion (Carrère & Gottman, 1999; University of Washington, 1999). In the larger newlywed study by Gottman, Coan, Carrère and Swanson (1998), 130 newlywed couples were followed to identify “marital interaction processes that are predictive of divorce or marital stability” (p. 5). The authors reported that “divorce and stability were predicted with 83% accuracy and satisfaction with 80% accuracy” (Gottman et al., 1998, p. 5). Among the patterns they described as predicting divorce were negative start-up and a lack of physiological soothing (Gottman et al., 1998).
Is arguing itself bad for a relationship?
The research does not say so. Gordon and Chen (2016) tested, across seven studies, “the overarching hypothesis that conflict in close relationships is only detrimental when people do not feel their thoughts, feelings, and point of view are understood by their relationship partners” (p. 239). They found that “conflict was negatively associated with relationship satisfaction among participants who perceived their romantic partner as less understanding, but not among those who felt more understood by their partners” (Gordon & Chen, 2016, p. 239). The authors also reported that perceived understanding was positively associated with conflict resolution (Gordon & Chen, 2016).
No receptionist, no intake forms. You start with a free 20-minute intro call with Samuel himself. If it isn’t the right fit, you’ll know in those 20 minutes.
Is gentle always better than direct?
Not in every case. Overall and McNulty (2017) argue that answering what constitutes effective conflict communication “requires (a) clarifying whether communication expresses opposition versus cooperation and is direct versus indirect” (p. 1), along with the mechanisms involved and the context. In their review, the best way to communicate during conflict depends on these factors rather than on one fixed rule (Overall & McNulty, 2017).
How does Samuel work with harsh startup in couples counselling?
Samuel Ezzatilord, PhD, RCC, CCC, LMCC, works with couples using the Gottman Method together with Internal Family Systems (IFS). In practice this means looking at how difficult conversations begin and what each partner is protecting when a conversation opens sharply. Sessions are held in person at 1500 West Georgia Street in downtown Vancouver or by secure video anywhere in BC, in English or Farsi. See couples and family therapy in Vancouver and Gottman Method couples therapy.
Frequently asked questions
Can the first few minutes of one argument really predict divorce?
The study measured couples’ affect during a laboratory conflict discussion and found that the first 3 minutes predicted marital outcome over six years (Carrère & Gottman, 1999). It describes a statistical association in that sample, not a verdict on any individual couple.
How many couples were studied?
124 newlywed couples in Carrère and Gottman (1999), and 130 newlywed couples in Gottman et al. (1998).
We argue a lot. Does that mean we are in trouble?
Gordon and Chen (2016) found conflict was negatively associated with satisfaction only among people who perceived their partner as less understanding.
Should I avoid raising problems so we don’t fight?
Overall and McNulty (2017) report that whether communication is direct or indirect, and cooperative or oppositional, matters, along with context; their review does not recommend avoiding problems as a general rule.
What if only one of us wants to come to counselling?
You can start alone. Samuel also sees individuals for relationship concerns.
Is couples counselling covered by ICBC, CVAP or extended health?
Couples sessions are often billed to extended health plans, and if relationship strain follows a car accident or a violent crime with an accepted claim, counselling may be funded. Fees and expenses are covered by ICBC, CVAP, FNHA, IFHP, RCMP, VAC, and most other insurers, and direct billing is available.
Do you offer couples counselling online?
Yes, by secure video anywhere in British Columbia.
Book a free 20-minute intro call
Call or WhatsApp 604-721-0604, or book at drsamuel.ca/book-a-call/. Appointments are available 7am–9pm, by appointment only, in person in downtown Vancouver or by video across BC. Fees and expenses are covered by ICBC, CVAP, FNHA, IFHP, RCMP, VAC, and most other insurers, and direct billing is available. جلسات به فارسی برگزار میشود.
Written with expert editorial assistance.
This article summarizes the cited sources for general information only. It is not medical, psychological or legal advice and does not replace an individual assessment.
References
- Carrère, S., & Gottman, J. M. (1999). Predicting divorce among newlyweds from the first three minutes of a marital conflict discussion. Family Process, 38(3), 293–301. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1545-5300.1999.00293.x
- Gordon, A. M., & Chen, S. (2016). Do you get where I’m coming from?: Perceived understanding buffers against the negative impact of conflict on relationship satisfaction. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 110(2), 239–260. https://doi.org/10.1037/pspi0000039
- Gottman, J. M., Coan, J., Carrère, S., & Swanson, C. (1998). Predicting marital happiness and stability from newlywed interactions. Journal of Marriage and the Family, 60(1), 5–22. https://doi.org/10.2307/353438
- Overall, N. C., & McNulty, J. K. (2017). What type of communication during conflict is beneficial for intimate relationships? Current Opinion in Psychology, 13, 1–5. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.copsyc.2016.03.002
- University of Washington. (1999, September 27). First three minutes of discussion about on-going area of marital conflict are predictive of divorce for newlyweds [News release]. https://washington.edu/news/1999/09/27/first-three-minutes-of-discussion-about-on-going-area-of-marital-conflict-are-predictive-of-divorce-for-newlyweds
Notice: For general interest only; may contain inaccuracies. Not a diagnosis, treatment, prognosis, or professional, clinical, or legal advice. Reading this creates no counsellor-client relationship. By reading this page, you agree to these terms. Full disclaimer. In an emergency, call 911.
